Insurance Analysis

English Setter

Is pet insurance worth it for a English Setter? We compare premiums against expected vet costs to find out which plans, if any, actually break even.

For your breed and state, self-insuring is likely more cost-effective than paying premiums.

$457 Expected medical
$17–$1,583 Medical range
low Risk tier
13 yrs Coverage period

Breakeven projection

Cumulative premiums vs. expected claims value over your English Setter's lifetime. When the teal line crosses above the terracotta line, insurance has paid for itself.

Self-insure may be betterLemonade · 13-year projection

All providers compared

15 providers ranked by ROI for a English Setter in California.

Best value

Lemonade

ROI -98%
Net value $-9,043
Monthly $59/mo
Total premiums $9,204
Expected claims $161
Deductible $250
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Unlimited annual limit available

ManyPets

ROI -98%
Net value $-9,667
Monthly $63/mo
Total premiums $9,828
Expected claims $161
Deductible $250
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Unlimited annual limit available

MetLife

ROI -98%
Net value $-12,741
Monthly $83/mo
Total premiums $12,948
Expected claims $207
Deductible $250
Reimbursement 100%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Dental illness included
  • Unlimited annual limit available

Pets Best

ROI -98%
Net value $-8,369
Monthly $55/mo
Total premiums $8,580
Expected claims $211
Deductible $200
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Unlimited annual limit available

Trupanion

ROI -98%
Net value $-12,425
Monthly $81/mo
Total premiums $12,636
Expected claims $211
Deductible $200
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Unlimited annual limit available
  • No orthopedic waiting period

AKC

ROI -99%
Net value $-11,071
Monthly $72/mo
Total premiums $11,232
Expected claims $161
Deductible $250
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Unlimited annual limit available

ASPCA

ROI -99%
Net value $-11,851
Monthly $77/mo
Total premiums $12,012
Expected claims $161
Deductible $250
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Dental illness included
  • Unlimited annual limit available

Nationwide

ROI -99%
Net value $-14,971
Monthly $97/mo
Total premiums $15,132
Expected claims $161
Deductible $250
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Dental illness included
  • Unlimited annual limit available

Pumpkin

ROI -99%
Net value $-12,943
Monthly $84/mo
Total premiums $13,104
Expected claims $161
Deductible $250
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Dental illness included
  • Unlimited annual limit available

Embrace

ROI -101%
Net value $-11,009
Monthly $70/mo
Total premiums $10,920
Expected claims $0
Deductible $500
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Dental illness included

Fetch by The Dodo

ROI -101%
Net value $-12,101
Monthly $77/mo
Total premiums $12,012
Expected claims $0
Deductible $500
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Dental illness included
  • Unlimited annual limit available

Healthy Paws

ROI -101%
Net value $-10,229
Monthly $65/mo
Total premiums $10,140
Expected claims $0
Deductible $500
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Unlimited annual limit available

Paw Protect

ROI -101%
Net value $-10,229
Monthly $65/mo
Total premiums $10,140
Expected claims $0
Deductible $500
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Unlimited annual limit available
  • No orthopedic waiting period

Spot

ROI -101%
Net value $-9,605
Monthly $61/mo
Total premiums $9,516
Expected claims $0
Deductible $500
Reimbursement 90%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Unlimited annual limit available

Figo

ROI -103%
Net value $-11,369
Monthly $71/mo
Total premiums $11,076
Expected claims $0
Deductible $750
Reimbursement 100%
  • Hereditary and congenital conditions covered
  • Bilateral condition coverage (both sides)
  • Unlimited annual limit available

Frequently asked questions

How much is pet insurance for a English Setter?

Pet insurance for a English Setter typically costs $33–$62 per month, with an average of $46/month. Premiums vary by your dog's age, your location, deductible, and reimbursement percentage.

What is the best pet insurance for a English Setter?

Based on our analysis, Lemonade offers the best value for English Setter owners. We evaluate plans based on breed-specific health risks, premium costs, coverage terms, and expected claim value over the dog's lifetime.

Is pet insurance worth it for a English Setter?

On expected value, pet insurance is optional for English Setter owners. As a large breed, the English Setter's expected health costs are usually below total premiums — coverage is better viewed as protection against a rare, catastrophic bill than as a way to save money.

When should I get insurance for my English Setter?

Enroll your English Setter as early as possible — ideally as a puppy. Most pet insurance plans have waiting periods (14–30 days for illness, 6–12 months for orthopedic conditions), and pre-existing conditions are excluded from coverage.

See the full cost breakdown and health risk analysis: